top of page

Why is it so hard for me to trust people?

  • Writer: Sherri M. Herman
    Sherri M. Herman
  • Oct 28
  • 3 min read

It’s hard to trust people because past experiences, fears of being hurt, and old survival patterns can make your nervous system see closeness as unsafe.


Text on a colorful abstract background reads: How do I stay emotionally grounded during chaos? and www.sherrimherman.com. Mood: thoughtful.

What does it really mean to “have difficulty trusting others”?

When people say they have a lack of trust in people, it usually isn’t about being suspicious of everyone. It’s more subtle. You might share surface-level parts of yourself but hold back the real stuff. You might wait for the other shoe to drop, even with someone who seems kind. Or you might second-guess every promise, apology, or commitment.


Difficulty trusting others is often less about other people and more about the ways your brain and body have learned to protect you due to past painful experiences.


Why is it hard to trust people if they haven’t done anything wrong?

Trust is built on history. If your past includes betrayal, neglect, criticism, or abandonment, your body remembers. Even when someone new is trustworthy, your nervous system may respond with fear of being hurt again.


It’s like having a smoke alarm that goes off not just for fire, but for toast. The alarm is trying to keep you safe, but it leaves you on edge. That’s why you might find yourself guarded even in relationships where there’s no clear reason.


How do survival roles play into lack of trust?

Many of us grew up in environments where we had to adopt roles to survive—caretaker, overachiever, peacekeeper, fixer. Those roles often trained us to rely on ourselves because other people weren’t consistent or safe (enough).


So as adults, trusting others feels risky. Letting go of control might feel impossible because your old survival role says: If I don’t manage this, I’ll get hurt and I might not survive. These roles once kept you safe. But now, they can leave you isolated when what you actually need is connection.


Can I learn to trust again?

Yes, learning to trust again is possible—but it’s not about suddenly giving your heart away or pretending everything is fine. It starts with small, steady steps:


  • Notice safe moments. Keep track of times when someone shows up, follows through, or respects your boundaries.

  • Share in layers. Instead of all-or-nothing, try offering small pieces of yourself and see how they’re handled.

  • Stay connected to your body. When you feel the urge to pull back, pause. Ask: Is this about now, or is this about the past?

  • Let trust be reciprocal. It isn’t just about giving trust—it’s also about noticing when others trust you. That mutual exchange helps build steadiness.


Trust grows like a muscle: slowly, through repetition.


How do I build trust in relationships without ignoring my fear?

Fear doesn’t disappear just because you want to trust someone. Instead of fighting it, you can bring it along for the ride. Try these steps:

  • Name the fear. Say to yourself: I’m afraid of being hurt, and that makes sense. Naming reduces its power.

  • Clarify your boundaries. Clear limits give you the confidence to open up without feeling exposed.

  • Choose safe people. Not everyone has earned your vulnerability. Start with those who are consistent, kind, and nonjudgmental.

  • Let time do its work. Trust isn’t built in a single leap—it’s built in a hundred small moments.

This way, you can honor your fear without letting it run the show.


When should I get help for trust issues?

If a lack of trust in people is keeping you isolated, sabotaging your relationships, or leaving you lonely, it may help to seek support. A therapist, support group, or even a trusted mentor can help you sort out the difference between old fears and current realities.

You don’t have to figure it all out alone—ironically, trust often grows when someone helps you hold the weight of it.


Final thoughts :

Trust isn’t about being naïve or ignoring risk. It’s about slowly allowing yourself to believe that not everyone will hurt you, that most people are trustworthy, and that connection can feel safe again.



FREE QUIZ

Discover Your Super Power that’s Secretly Draining You 

If you’re struggling to trust, it may be because you’re operating in your “superpower mode” that once helped you but now quietly gets in the way. I created a free quiz to help you name yours—and see how to step out of it.



Comments


bottom of page